•

Import LC Discrepancy Approval Workflow for Finance

A blank document inspected inside a glass box, with paths stopping before a separate empty frame.
What’s in this article?

    Build a presentation-specific decision packet before accepting discrepant import documents. Keep internal approval, the bank’s response, document disposition and the eventual debit separately evidenced.

    A bank sends an import letter-of-credit discrepancy notice. Purchasing wants the shipment released, logistics is worried about a document, and treasury needs to know what it is being asked to authorize. An email saying “approved” does not establish which discrepancies were reviewed—or what the bank subsequently did.

    This import LC discrepancy approval workflow is for an importer’s finance and treasury team coordinating a response to its bank. It starts with one identified document presentation and ends with the bank outcome, financial movements and accounting review explained. The controls below are recommended company practices, not universal banking rules or instructions to accept a particular discrepancy.

    Separate the importer’s decision from the bank’s outcome

    An importer’s willingness to accept discrepant documents is one decision; the issuing bank’s handling of that presentation is another. Your credit, bank agreement, applicable rules and actual advice determine the process. Do not assume a bank must ask for or accept a waiver.

    For example, section 3.5 of HSBC’s Germany Standard Trade Terms says HSBC may reject a noncomplying claim and is not obliged to seek the customer’s waiver. That is an example from specific bank terms, not a substitute for checking your own agreement.

    Use four independent fields: internal decision, authorized response sent, bank outcome and settlement evidence. A commercial manager accepting a delivery problem does not prove that an authorized instruction reached the bank. Nor does a submitted response prove that an account was debited.

    This is different from the exporter’s documentary collection workflow, which manages collection instructions and D/P or D/A document release. Do not transfer that method’s assumptions to a documentary credit.

    Open a case for the exact presentation

    Assign a finance case owner when the bank’s advice arrives. Use the LC reference and the drawing or presentation reference: several presentations under one credit must not inherit one blanket approval.

    • Identity: applicant legal entity, beneficiary, issuing bank, LC number, presentation reference, currency, drawing amount and related purchase order.
    • Current terms: credit and relevant amendments, bank advice, presented-document versions and the complete discrepancy list supplied by the bank.
    • Time: advice received, the bank’s requested response deadline and time zone, internal review cutoff, shipment location and any logistics decision dates.
    • Authority: preparer, commercial and logistics reviewers, treasury reviewer and authorized bank signatory or portal authorizer.
    • Outcome: decision version, transmitted response, bank acknowledgment, confirmed handling, document disposition, payment or maturity details, charges and posting references.

    Confirm unclear deadlines directly with the bank. Set an earlier internal cutoff under company policy; do not treat a general bank examination period as the importer’s response allowance. If the advice or supporting document is missing, request it immediately and record who is following up. Silence is not an internal approval method.

    Review each discrepancy before combining the decision

    Commercial acceptance needs a stated basis

    Purchasing should explain whether the actual transaction remains acceptable under the commercial agreement. Record the affected requirement, operational impact, evidence reviewed and proposed treatment. “Supplier is trusted” is not a substitute for explaining a late shipment, inconsistent quantity or missing document.

    Ask the bank or appropriate trade adviser to resolve documentary questions; do not relabel an item “minor” solely because it looks like a typographical error. Keep any underlying goods dispute visible rather than treating an LC response as its automatic resolution.

    Logistics and treasury answer different questions

    Logistics reviews whether the documents and shipment arrangements create an unresolved delivery, transport or clearance issue. Relevant specialists determine legal or regulatory questions. Treasury reviews drawing amount, currency, timing, funding, bank charges and the authorized instruction route.

    A company decision to tolerate a commercial issue does not cure a legal restriction or instruct a carrier to release goods. If a review cannot be completed before the requested deadline, escalate to the authorized decision maker and contact the bank about the available handling. Record the bank’s actual answer rather than assuming an extension.

    Use a decision and transition matrix

    Copy these fields into your case record. The states are an internal coordination model—not a bank’s status vocabulary or an automated rule for honoring documents.

    Import LC discrepancy response control matrix
    Trigger and stateOwner and required evidenceControl and exceptionNext state and finance consequence
    Advice received → Review openFinance owner: bank reference, current credit, amount, full discrepancy list and response deadlineMatch the actual presentation; request missing pages or unclear instructionsEvidence collection; no acceptance or payment inferred
    Evidence assembled → Decision proposedPurchasing and logistics: item-by-item risk assessment, supporting records and unresolved issuesEscalate unsupported conclusions; do not hide an unresolved discrepancy in a general approvalProposal ready or blocked; record exposure and next action
    Proposal reviewed → Response authorizedDelegated approver and treasury: exact response, presentation scope, financial terms and authorityApprove the complete version; changed advice or instruction returns to reviewAuthorized for submission, not bank accepted or settled
    Authorized response → Sent to bankAuthorized banking user: final response, transmission reference and timestampA draft or saved portal instruction is not proof of sending; verify any required second authorizationBank outcome pending; retain acknowledgment and follow-up date
    Bank reports outcome → Outcome evidencedTreasury: matched bank advice, actual document disposition and any payment/maturity detailsClarify rejection, qualifications or a new discrepancy; keep the prior instruction traceablePayment, maturity follow-up or unresolved case, as actually evidenced
    Financial event → Reconciled and reviewedAccounting: bank debit, fees, funding/loan records where relevant, invoice allocation and posting referencesExplain differences; do not clear an obligation twice or manufacture a balancing feeClose only after required financial and document tasks are resolved

    Retain a row for each discrepancy: bank wording, document/version, business consequence, reviewer, evidence, proposed response, final decision and approval version. Add a case-level statement identifying whether the response addresses the complete notice. If different treatment is proposed for individual items, obtain the bank’s guidance on the instruction it will accept; do not invent a selective-waiver mechanism.

    Authorize and send the response—not just the assessment

    NAB’s import LC instructions distinguish an acceptance instruction responding to a noncomplying presentation from a payment instruction supplying settlement details. Its submission flow can still leave a transaction pending bank approval or another authorizer, depending on the profile.

    Make the handoff explicit: the preparer attaches the decision packet; the authorized user checks the exact presentation, decision and supporting authority; the sender retains the submitted version and transmission record. Check the final banking status rather than treating an internal approval or success screen as proof of the eventual financial result.

    A refusal also needs a completed transmission path. Westpac New Zealand’s import LC guide specifically notes that refusal instructions still require approval to be sent to the bank. Use your bank’s current procedure and authorized users, not another bank’s button sequence.

    Changed advice invalidates the assumed scope

    If the bank supplies a revised discrepancy list, drawing amount or presentation reference before submission, stop the internal handoff and compare versions. Obtain renewed approval for the affected response. Preserve the superseded packet rather than overwriting the record of what was reviewed.

    If a response was already sent, contact the bank promptly about the changed facts and permitted next action. Record its handling; do not assume that deleting an internal task withdraws a bank instruction or that a second message cancels the first.

    Track bank handling, documents and money separately

    The ICC Banking Commission case analysis in DC Insight discusses document holding pending an applicant waiver and the bank agreeing to accept that waiver. Preserve the distinction in your own record: an applicant decision is not the entire bank outcome.

    Obtain advice matched to this presentation. Record what the bank actually confirms about handling and document disposition. For a term drawing, retain the evidenced maturity and a funding follow-up owner; do not label it paid merely because an acceptance-related event occurred.

    At settlement, match the drawing reference, bank movement, supported charges and any financing record. If an import loan funds the drawing, review that liability and subsequent repayment separately rather than assuming the operating account had the same cash movement as a directly funded payment. Accounting determines recognition, allocation, exchange differences and entries under the applicable framework. The operational status itself is not a posting rule.

    Worked example: an approved response with an open difference

    Illustrative sight-LC case: a business receives discrepancy advice for a USD 40,000 drawing. The reviewers document their assessment, the authorized signatory approves the exact response and an authorized user sends it. The bank later confirms its handling and advises a USD 40,000 drawing plus USD 150 in charges. Assume direct USD account funding, no tax or FX and no other transactions.

    1. Finance preserves the advice and approved response for this presentation, including the reasons for the decision. It does not mark the case settled on approval.
    2. Treasury records the bank-confirmed document disposition and matches a USD 40,150 account debit: USD 40,000 drawing plus USD 150 supported charges.
    3. Accounting reviews the invoice/obligation allocation and charge treatment, records actual posting references and checks that no duplicate payment task remains active.
    4. The case closes only when the required document, financial and review tasks have evidence. The example does not establish that accepting discrepancies resolves any separate supplier claim.

    If the actual debit is USD 40,230, the extra USD 80 stays open. Treasury requests the breakdown and assigns a follow-up date; the preparer does not silently increase the fee line to force agreement. If revised advice arrives before the original response is sent, return the affected decision to approval rather than reusing the prior signature.

    Where Workhint fits

    Workhint’s Workflow Engine describes role-based approval routing and requirements for details, files or notes before work advances. That supports the internal coordination problem: collecting the assessment, assigning reviewers and requiring the response evidence.

    The Workflow Automation Software solution describes structured requests and tracking stages, approvals, owners and next actions. A proposed configuration could keep “review incomplete,” “authorized but not sent” and “bank outcome pending” distinct, with an owner for each. Validate that design against the team’s actual requirements.

    These pages do not establish native LC document examination, SWIFT connectivity, banking authority, automatic trade compliance or ledger posting. The authorized bank channel handles bank instructions; bank records and the accounting system remain the evidence sources for financial outcomes.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can purchasing alone accept the discrepancies?

    Purchasing can assess the commercial issue, but the bank-facing response must follow the company’s delegated authority and the bank’s authorized instruction process. Record both the assessment and the final authorized response.

    Does an importer’s waiver guarantee payment?

    No. Do not infer the bank’s outcome from the internal decision. Confirm the handling under the actual credit, bank terms and advice, then retain the relevant payment or maturity evidence.

    Can one approval cover later drawings under the same LC?

    Do not assume so. Link each decision to its presentation, discrepancy notice and approved scope. A changed or later presentation needs review under the applicable authority and bank process.

    When should finance leave the case open?

    Keep it open while required review, transmission, bank handling, document disposition or financial reconciliation evidence is unresolved. Assign the next action and owner instead of replacing uncertainty with a “paid” label.

    Comments

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


    The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.